Tool vs. A Perfect Circle: Famous Rockers & Fans Debate Who Is Better

Photo credit: Lauryn Schaffner for

Alternative Nation reporter Lauryn Schaffner recently asked Three Days Grace, Them Evils, and fans at the Rock on the Range festival which Maynard James Keenan fronted band they preferred: Tool or A Perfect Circle. Both bands were performing at the Columbus, Ohio based festival. Watch below!

The Baldy has posted the following on the Alice In Chains tour blog:

Tool and Alice In Chains have a long history together, going back to 1993 when they spent the summer together Lollapalooza-ing across North America.

Tool was one of my favorite bands on the bill that summer.

They came onstage in the middle of the afternoon and absolutely killed it day after day after day.

And Maynard was a whirling dervish of activity, at least compared to now.

He prowled the stage and stomped and kicked and spun around until he fell over.

And the band was tight and brutal.

Those guys were (and are) an incredible band.

One of my favorite drunkenly fuzzy memories from Lollapaooza was going to an after hours bar after the show in Atlanta, and sitting between Maynard and Layne at the bar.

As the night turned into morning and more and more drinks were ingested, Layne & Maynard decided that talking was interfering with their drinking, so they decided to quit.

Talking, not drinking.

For what seemed like an hour, they used me to pass notes back and forth to each other on cocktail napkins. I can’t remember what all was written, but the notes were strange and hilarious, and that night will always stick with me.